Ruxith Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 I know this is something we've wanted for a while - a kit fisto head/model that's "better" than the old versions. A couple months ago when we all started frankensteining I had the help of two modeler friends of mine mostly for the weighting, and we put this together: It's not the final design, this series of screenshots was done months ago just to test how the heads looked on the different skin variants. Some of you have seen it already, most of you haven't.. it's nothing for me to brag about because I didn't make the model (clearly xD) and the reskins are very basic.. just making sure certain patterns are aligned right for the sith version and re-testing in modview until it looks right, and an RGB version which is simple enough to create anyway. I just wanted to ask if this kind of thing is likely to be accepted if I uploaded it to JKHub before uploading it to just get rejected? I know it contains ported content so that's why I wanted to ask first. Voh Phaar, GPChannel, Maksman and 11 others like this
z3filus Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 as far as I know, ported models are almost never accepted, and with partly ported (head only e.g.) it comes down to how much you've altered it.I had a ported Ezio Auditore from AC2 and even with team skins it wasn't seen "legit" , it was refused for not being altered enough, as I recall....so good luck with this, I really like this new Kit Fisto, compared to the JK2 one... could u send this to me? for private use. GPChannel likes this
Kualan Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 Yeah it all depends on how much it has been altered from the original source, and what decides that is entirely at the discretion of the staff. I've made mention of this in a recent profile status but I might as well raise it here too since the staff will probably read this topic - does this policy extend to games that have been closed down and can be considered abandonware such as Star Wars Galaxies, Clone Wars Adventures, etc?
Vitéz Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 I doubt this is a full port, Ruxith said it contains ported parts. The body and the robe looks like HS Anakin's body and robe... if its true, there wont be any problem, because there are a lot of frankeinseined model here on JKHub what contains ported parts from SWToR, and they were accepted... note: it'd be wise to replace the base human hands to Kit Fisto's hands.
AshuraDX Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 this could probably get trough - as only the head is taken from TFU and the rest was done by hapslash@@Kualan we have rejected models ported from CWA before and content from star wars galaxies has been rejected recently I'm not sure how them being abandonware would effect our decision here... @@eezstreet @@therfiles @@Barricade24 therfiles likes this
Kualan Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 this could probably get trough - as only the head is taken from TFU and the rest was done by hapslash@@Kualan we have rejected models ported from CWA before and content from star wars galaxies has been rejected recently I'm not sure how them being abandonware would effect our decision here... @@eezstreet @@therfiles @@Barricade24 Thanks for clarifying. I'll keep them as private models.
AshuraDX Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 @@Kualan do that for now - how many parts have been ported from SWG ?pm pictures of the model to me if you want me to take a look
Kualan Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 It's much like this one - heads of various species being ported over then stuck on a base JKA model (in this case, Hapslash Jedi). I'll PM you some shots.
therfiles Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 Hmm, an interesting question. I think each staff member, when approving files, has their own way of weighing what is an "acceptable" amount of ported content. In my opinion, if this model came down the pipeline I would accept it. Here are the reasons:Only the head is portedThe head has been re-skinned.Those are significant changes that I could accept, personally. This is my personal way, and does not reflect the official opinion of JKHub. Also, I don't think the age of the game the content comes through would really affect our decision. It's all owned by a corporate entity so it's a legal mess either way. I've seen plenty of people port JKA models into other games, probably since they consider our game "abandoned". Crazy stuff. But no, I'd say keep ported content in moderation, and it needs some sort of modification to really make it acceptable. Kualan likes this
z3filus Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 Yeah it all depends on how much it has been altered from the original source, and what decides that is entirely at the discretion of the staff. I've made mention of this in a recent profile status but I might as well raise it here too since the staff will probably read this topic - does this policy extend to games that have been closed down and can be considered abandonware such as Star Wars Galaxies, Clone Wars Adventures, etc?such as Jedi Academy & Jedi Outcast
Kualan Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 such as Jedi Academy & Jedi Outcast I know you're just joshing, but there is actually a distinction to be made there. JO and JKA are still sold to customers, i.e. it is a product still in circulation. You can't buy/download SWG, CWA, etc anymore, they've been completely removed from the market. Which, it could be argued, is a sign of abandonment of the copyright on those individual properties. It's a moot point anyway - the staff have clarified their position, but yeah, just thought I'd point that out as a little FYI.
z3filus Posted August 26, 2015 Posted August 26, 2015 yeah but you're clearly onto something here, I think the staff here should reconcider their policies..does it really make this game not dead/ forgotten/ abandoned/no 1 gives a f*ck .. if the price tag is maybe 4 euros?LucasArts is down, so down infact, that their closest neighbour is a dinosaur, which is also a good metaphor for JediKnight.So who do you think is going to care more about ported models; game developers or the staff of Jkhub.org ? ? yeah.. hmm... Wasa and Delmi like this
Ruxith Posted August 26, 2015 Author Posted August 26, 2015 Okay thanks for the replies i'll try and get around to finishing it in the next few weeks when I get some more free time and upload it. I guess I should probably try and finish that savage opress in my sig too.. therfiles, Omega and Daedra like this
Omega Posted August 27, 2015 Posted August 27, 2015 I would very much like to see this kit fisto model released, very awesome I think! As well as you said finishing up the savage opress in your sig. I would really like to see these released, I don't see it being an issue if content is uploaded on this site if it's not a full port due to the rules on jkhub like what the others were saying earlier on this topic. I say continue your awesome work and upload away!
Veosar Posted September 2, 2015 Posted September 2, 2015 Any progress on that one? Really looking forward to updates, if you did any, of course.
Ruxith Posted September 2, 2015 Author Posted September 2, 2015 Patience is a virtue. As I stated i'm busy at the moment, i'll post something or upload it when I find the time. Shouldn't be long now, can probably find some time again next week. JAWSFreelao, Srethem and yeyo JK like this
Gronkie Posted December 24, 2015 Posted December 24, 2015 Any news of how your little project is going? Looks amazing!
Daedra Posted April 16, 2016 Posted April 16, 2016 Patience is a virtue. As I stated i'm busy at the moment, i'll post something or upload it when I find the time. Shouldn't be long now, can probably find some time again next week. It's been quite a few months now, and I love the work you've currently done. Any updates since last September? yeyo JK and Ruxith like this
Ruxith Posted April 17, 2016 Author Posted April 17, 2016 XD yeah I guess patience really is a virtue now hey!Hopefully I can find some time to get back onto releasing the things I promised soon. I also have a few new stuff I started that I haven't gotten around to finishing aswell, ffs rux.Working 6 days a week sucks! Daedra likes this
Daedra Posted April 19, 2016 Posted April 19, 2016 XD yeah I guess patience really is a virtue now hey!Hopefully I can find some time to get back onto releasing the things I promised soon. I also have a few new stuff I started that I haven't gotten around to finishing aswell, ffs rux.Working 6 days a week sucks! The only reason I bumped is because first I really want this! But second I was wondering if you could include the Battlefront version of Kit Fisto (shirtless) : yeyo JK likes this
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now