Jump to content

hleV

Members
  • Posts

    291
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by hleV

  1. Makes no difference when establishing what's canon and what's not. Not sure what you mean by non-existent, but regarding non-canon, yes, and you cannot do anything about it. As far as Star Wars actual continuity is concerned, those stories are gone. Feel free to keep them in your imaginary world (not saying that in a bad sense), but don't try to push them into what truly happened in Star Wars. I like DF/JK/KOTOR, but I won't claim that they're part of the continuity just because I'd like them to be.
  2. It is not for you or "many other people" to decide what "truly happened" in Star Wars continuity. If facts aren't facts, then what the fuck are they?
  3. And I'm pointing out that your point of view is invalid. You're trying to push the idea that "everything depends on your point of view" which is incorrect. Nothing depends on it if it outright contradicts the established facts and you live in your own ilusionary world.
  4. @@Cerez, yet another post where you write worthless crap such as "things are not necessarily the way you see" without anything to back it up. Things aren't like that because I see them that way, things are that way because there are facts to prove it. You can create your own imaginary worlds as much as you like but don't try to push your own opinion, which conflicts with established facts, as a possibility, because it is not. It only becomes true if someone with the rights to Star Wars comes and says so, effectively retconning what's already established.
  5. Rogue One is canon and most likely retcons Dark Forces, that's all there is to it. You can like whatever you want, but you can't change the fact that something is canon and something is not by simply prefering something more to another. The two posts above mine are absolute bullcrap and prove nothing. "There is philosophy and shit." The fuck do I care? There are established facts. Deal with it.
  6. And Earth is flat because I'd like it to be flat. Established facts are not arguable. If you think they are, you are wrong. I myself have multiple times claimed that the shit that is TCW or Rebels is non-canon, but that was a means to portray my dissatisfaction with them, I don't actually believe my word is above the rights holders when it comes to establishing canon. Though I guess it's arguable if the established facts conflict with each other. I can still cherish the original trilogy and tell everything else to go fuck themselves.
  7. "I like Kyle Katarn so he's canon and the actually canon stuff is not." That's not how it works. You cannot have an opinion that goes against established facts. Can you call them bullshit, though? Definitely. Realizing something is bad is one thing, but there's no need to get delusional.
  8. Cool idea. I've always kind of wanted something like this for MB2 Duel maps. Is there a KOTOR1 counterpart? (I realize KOTOR1 had less of memorable duels.)
  9. Then what the fuck was it about? Blowing up Death Stars?
  10. I had the exact same issue the other day, however doing all the steps exactly the way they're written in that Steam troubleshooting page did fix it for me.
  11. Whey the fuck do they bring back new Inquisitors with that retarded saber...
  12. That shit is only acceptable to those blinded by their love for Star Wars. "It's Star Wars, it can't be bad!"
  13. It's no longer April Fools here and I wasn't even surprised when I saw this. But it's a good thing that it's fake.
  14. New one.
  15. The older Ahsoka looks fine to me.
  16. Stances is one thing, but I think SWTOR animations are terrible.
  17. That 5 FPS video.
  18. In the movies enemy is taken seriously and the cast is often saved by luck (aka not-so-obvious plot armor) while in the show nobody cares that there are 10 stormtroopers 10 meters away shooting at you.
  19. Oh then I guess the cast was just silly to put this much effort into escaping/fighting them, because as evident in Rebels, there's no need for any effort. And never have I said that Stormtroopers are the shit. All I'm pointing out is that there is a marginal difference between the movie and the show logic, which separates their universes.
  20. Two contradictory things cannot coexist in the same universe. The movies follow different logic than the show (and possibly other media). I'm done, as apparently you're having problems grasping this simple fact.
  21. It would crop the view instead of expanding it, though, putting you at a disadvantage for the mere fact that you're on widescreen (which OpenJK fixed with cg_fovaspectadjust CVAR).
  22. You can apply the logic that is seen in the movies, because that's the source material. It does and there is. One is the source material and another is portraying Star Wars as something it isn't: a kids' thing that doesn't follow previously established logic because it's for kids, which makes fine for marketing but not fine for staying in the canon. If EU or whatever else Star Wars-shit contradicts the actual "Star Wars" then fuck that, non-canon. However your chosen examples are invalid and don't back up your claims. I don't disrespect you. I disagree with you.
  23. "The same way X did Y" is not an argument and doesn't answer any question. You're just providing something else that according to you is comparable, but don't provide an argument for why it makes sense. I perfecty realize that different media may be for different audiences and be "expressed" in different ways. I'm saying that it doesn't make sense for events that are supposed to be in the same universe to have different kind of world logic applied to them. Your ghosts/droids/Force/magic examples are absolutely nonsensical and irrelevant, by the way. I honestly can't tell what's going on in your head to write this shit. They're all different things, whereas fighting 10 trained and armed people is just one (yet different between the show and the movies).
×
×
  • Create New...